Phone: (914) 381-2400E-Mail:

Comparing ABS vs. Polycarbonate for Durability

Plastic Resin Suppliers

Advice from Plastic Resin Suppliers

Many manufacturers face uncertainty when deciding between ABS and polycarbonate. The choice is often driven by conflicting priorities: budget constraints, impact strength requirements, and operating temperature conditions. Selecting the wrong material can result in premature product failure, increased warranty claims, and damage to reputation.

The importance of accurately distinguishing the durability of ABS and polycarbonate is clear; choosing the correct resin can significantly reduce failures in real-world applications. For projects demanding long-term durability under impact stress, high temperatures, or chemical exposure, polycarbonate consistently outperforms ABS.

What makes polycarbonate superior in impact strength?

Understanding impact strength is critical for products that must withstand accidental drops or regular physical stresses. Impact strength measures how well a material absorbs sudden force without cracking or breaking. Polycarbonate exhibits an impact strength near 600 joules per meter, significantly higher than ABS, which typically achieves around 80 joules per meter.

This difference lies in polycarbonate's molecular structure. Polycarbonate is composed of tightly linked bisphenol groups. When subjected to impact, these strong chemical bonds distribute energy throughout the polymer chains, preventing localized failures. ABS, by contrast, includes rubber domains intended to absorb shocks, but at lower temperatures, these domains become rigid, greatly reducing impact strength.

Practical testing clearly supports these results. For instance, according to ASTM D256 standardized Izod impact tests, polycarbonate maintains impact resilience at temperatures as low as -20°C, whereas ABS becomes brittle under these conditions.

Therefore, polycarbonate offers significant durability advantages over ABS for products exposed to physical impacts, especially in cold environments.

How do ABS and polycarbonate differ in heat tolerance?

The operating temperature of a product can drastically affect material performance. Heat deflection temperature (HDT) is a critical factor, indicating the temperature at which plastic begins deforming under load.

  • Polycarbonate has a high HDT of approximately 130°C at 1.8 MPa load, ensuring structural integrity in environments exposed to heat from electronic components or engines.
  • ABS offers a lower HDT, around 95°C under similar conditions, making it less suitable in environments involving continuous high heat.

Long-term heat exposure tests further validate polycarbonate's superior thermal stability. According to industry studies (ASTM D638), after 1,000 hours of prolonged exposure at 100°C, polycarbonate retains approximately 80% of its original tensile strength. ABS strength decreases significantly, falling below 50% under identical testing.

This data confirms polycarbonate as the recommended choice for parts consistently subjected to elevated temperatures.

Which material better withstands chemical exposure and UV radiation?

Product durability often requires resistance to chemical substances and prolonged exposure to sunlight. ABS offers reasonable resistance to general cleaning agents but is susceptible to solvents like alcohols, acetone, and gasoline, leading to surface degradation and structural weakening over time.

Polycarbonate demonstrates far superior chemical resistance, especially against alcohols and petroleum-based solvents. However, it can experience UV-related degradation, manifesting as yellowing or reduced clarity when used outdoors without stabilization.

Fortunately, manufacturers can overcome this limitation by using UV-stabilized polycarbonate or clear protective coatings. Such additives significantly extend outdoor life without compromising transparency, a feature critical in optical applications.

In environments involving solvent exposure or outdoor UV conditions, stabilized polycarbonate formulations provide clear advantages over ABS.

Are PC-ABS alloys a viable compromise?

Manufacturers seeking a balanced option between the properties of ABS and polycarbonate frequently select PC-ABS blends. Such alloys combine the benefits of both resins, delivering:

  • Improved impact strength (typically around 200 joules per meter)
  • Moderate heat tolerance, with an HDT around 110°C
  • Easier processing compared to pure polycarbonate

This hybrid solution works effectively in industries like consumer electronics, automotive dashboards, and portable tools, providing sufficient toughness without the higher costs associated with pure polycarbonate formulations.

Making an informed material choice

Choosing between ABS and polycarbonate depends on clearly understanding your product's real-world demands. While polycarbonate offers superior impact resistance, heat tolerance, and chemical durability, ABS is a more cost-effective choice for moderate performance needs. You can make confident, effective material decisions that ensure long-term product success by evaluating your specific application requirements and working with knowledgeable resin suppliers.

Related Reading